Jake is not as passionate as Edward so the book was not as exciting but it is still a good book. I just hate how in the beginning of the book Edward wants to buy her a nice car and she doesn't want to take it! I would love to have a new car. I picture her truck to be really cold inside, for some reason I don't think the heater works?. But I love how Edward takes her to prom and it's super hot that she has two guys wanting her. I would pick Edward all the way!